Prosper Growth And Usuary Laws
As can be observed from my analysis of Prosper's August income, they need to do some growing if they intend to survive long term. Prosper's ability to expand it's lending has been limited by the various state usury laws that limit the interest rates that lenders can fetch. This has been highlighted by Prosper Lending Review's commentary on the Pennsylvania rate cap and one borrower's attempt to get a loan despite the state's cap. The question, though, is how much can Prosper grow it's available market by navigating the various state usury laws.
To answer this question, lets look the populations for all the US states (circa 2005). The top 20 states represent about 75% of US population, and improving the borrowing and lending options in any one of these would be a tremendous boost to Prosper's available market. I've ranked each state based on Prosper's current loan limits with ratings of Excellent (loans above 20%, AA-HR likely to fund), Good (loans 20% - 17.5%, AA-C likely to fund), Marginal (loans 17.5% - 12.5%, AA-B likely to fund), or Poor (loans 12.5% - 10%, only AA's likely to fund), Very Poor (loans under 10% - good luck getting anything). The ratings were roughly derived from Prosper's 30-day interest rate average.
State | Population | Max Rate | Rating |
California | 36.1M | 30% | Excellent |
Texas | 22.8M | (Personal) 10% (Business) 18% | Marginal |
New York | 19.2M | 16% | Marginal |
Florida | 17.8M | 18% | Good |
Illinois | 12.7M | 30% | Excellent |
Pennsylvania | 12.4M | 6% | Very Poor |
Ohio | 11.4M | 25% | Excellent |
Michigan | 10.1M | 25% | Excellent |
Georgia | 9.0M | 30% | Excellent |
New Jersey | 8.7M | 16% | Marginal |
North Carolina | 8.7M | 30% | Excellent |
Virginia | 7.6M | 12% | Poor |
Massachutes | 6.4M | 20% | Good |
Washington | 6.3M | 25% | Excellent |
Indiana | 6.3M | 21% | Excellent |
Tennessee | 6.0M | 12.25% | Poor |
Arizona | 5.9M | 30% | Excellent |
Missouri | 5.8M | 30% | Excellent |
Maryland | 5.6M | 24% | Excellent |
Wisconsin | 5.5M | 18% | Good |
It's important to remember that a majority of Prosper's loans (dollar weighted) come from the B - D credit ratings, and, from the analysis, it's obvious that Prosper has a fair number of pick-up opportunities if they can get their legal ducks in a row for the states that require additional licensing to loan at higher rates (like Pennsylvania). After all, there's almost 77 million people in those marginal states.
1 comment:
How do you feel about it now? 9 May 2009
Post a Comment